The original re-watch schedule is below. Now, after we're through, the dates are of no importance anymore, of course. Other than for showing how lucky we were in planning the re-watch to end exactly the week before the season 5 premier on April 5, 2024.
The links below lead directly to each bullet point list that I made while and after watching each episode. The links above bring you to the top of every season's page. As I said on the intro page: Some bullet points are reactions to certain scenes, some are more fully formed thoughts. These lists, and this should go without saying, are full of spoilers. Don't say I haven't warned you.
24 Sep 23 - S1E01 "The Vulcan Hello" & S1E02 "Battle at the Binary Stars"
01 Oct 23 - S1E03 "Context is for Kings" & S1E04 "The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry"
08 Oct 23 - S1E05 "Choose Your Pain" & S1E06 "Lethe"
15 Oct 23 - S1E07 "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad" & S1E08 "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum"
22 Oct 23 - S1E09 "Into the Forest I Go" & S1E10 "Despite Yourself"
29 Oct 23 - S1E11 "The Wolf Inside" & S1E12 "Vaulting Ambition"
05 Nov 23 - S1E13 "What's Past is Prologue" & S1E14 "The War Within, The War Without"
12 Nov 23 - S1E15 "Will You Take My Hand?" & S2E01 "Brother"
19 Nov 23 - S2E02 "New Eden" & S2E03 "Point of Light"
26 Nov 23 - S2E04 "An Obol for Charon" & S2E05 "Saints of Imperfection"
03 Dec 23 - S2E06 "The Sound of Thunder" & S2E07 "Light and Shadows"
10 Dec 23 - S2E08 "If Memory Serves" & S2E09 "Project Daedalus"
17 Dec 23 - S2E10 "The Red Angel" & S2E11 "Perpetual Infinity"
24 Dec 23 - S2E12 "Through the Valley of Shadows"
31 Dec 23 - S2E13 "Such Sweet Sorrow, Part I" & S2E14 "Such Sweet Sorrow, Part II"
07 Jan 24 - S3E01 "That Hope is You, Part I" & S3E02 "Far From Home"
14 Jan 24 - S3E03 "People of Earth" & S3E04 "Forget Me Not"
21 Jan 24 - S3E05 "Die Trying" & S3E06 "Scavengers"
28 Jan 24 - S3E07 "Unification III" & S3E08 "The Sanctuary"
04 Feb 24 - S3E09 "Terra Firma, Part I" & S3E10 "Terra Firma, Part II"
11 Feb 24 - S3E11 "Su'Kal" & S3E12 "There is a Tide"
18 Feb 24 - S3E13 "That Hope is You, Part II" & S4E01 "Kobayashi Maru"
25 Feb 24 - S4E02 "Anomaly" & S4E03 "Choose To Live"
03 Mar 24 - S4E04 "All is Possible" & S4E05 "The Examples"
10 Mar 24 - S4E06 "Stormy Weather" & S4E07 "But to Connect"
17 Mar 24 - S4E08 "All In" & S4E09 "Rubicon"
24 Mar 24 - S4E10 "The Galactic Barrier" & S4E11 "Rosetta"
31 Mar 24 - S4E12 "Species Ten-C" & S4E13 "Coming Home"
04 Apr 24 - S5E01 "Red Directive" & S5E02 "Under The Twin Moon"
11 Apr 24 - S5E03 "Jinaal"
18 Apr 24 - S5E04 "Face The Strange"
25 Apr 24 - S5E05 "Mirrors"
02 May 24 - S5E06 "Whistlespeak"
09 May 24 - S5E07 "Erigah"
16 May 24 - S5E08 "Labyrinths"
23 May 24 - S5E09 "Lagrange Point"
30 May 24 - S5E10 "Life, Itself"